Isoniazid vs Other TB Drugs: Detailed Comparison of Alternatives

Isoniazid vs Other TB Drugs: Detailed Comparison of Alternatives

TB Drug Comparison Tool

This tool compares key attributes of Isoniazid and other anti-TB drugs to help understand their roles in treating tuberculosis.

Isoniazid

Class: First-line bactericidal

Dosage: 5 mg/kg daily (max 300 mg)

Uses: Latent TB, part of 4-drug regimen

Side Effects: Hepatotoxicity, peripheral neuropathy

Resistance Risk: Low when used with other first-line drugs

Rifampin

Class: First-line bactericidal

Dosage: 10 mg/kg daily (max 600 mg)

Uses: Active TB, part of 4-drug regimen

Side Effects: Hepatic enzyme rise, orange fluids, interactions

Resistance Risk: Moderate; synergy reduces risk

Ethambutol

Class: First-line bacteriostatic

Dosage: 15–25 mg/kg daily

Uses: Active TB, especially high-bacillary load

Side Effects: Optic neuritis, color vision loss

Resistance Risk: Low when combined

Pyrazinamide

Class: First-line bactericidal (acidic pH)

Dosage: 20–25 mg/kg daily (2 months)

Uses: Intensive-phase drug in standard regimen

Side Effects: Hepatotoxicity, hyperuricemia

Resistance Risk: Low with proper combination

Streptomycin

Class: Second-line injectable aminoglycoside

Dosage: 15 mg/kg IM daily

Uses: MDR-TB, when oral options limited

Side Effects: Ototoxicity, nephrotoxicity

Resistance Risk: High if used alone

Levofloxacin

Class: Fluoroquinolone (second-line)

Dosage: 750 mg daily

Uses: MDR-TB, rifampin-intolerant cases

Side Effects: Tendon rupture, QT prolongation

Resistance Risk: Moderate; resistance develops quickly

Bedaquiline

Class: Diarylquinoline (novel)

Dosage: 400 mg daily 2 wks, then 200 mg TIW

Uses: MDR-TB, part of all-oral regimens

Side Effects: QT prolongation, hepatic effects

Resistance Risk: Low when combined with other new drugs

Quick Decision Guide

  • Latent Infection: Isoniazid alone for 6-9 months or 3-month weekly Isoniazid-Rifapentine combo
  • Drug-Sensitive Pulmonary TB: Four-drug regimen (INH, RIF, EMB, PZA) for 2 months, followed by INH-RIF for 4 months
  • Hepatic Impairment: Reduce or omit INH and PZA; consider RIF, EMB, and fluoroquinolone
  • Pregnancy: Safe to use INH and RIF; avoid Streptomycin due to fetal ototoxicity
  • MDR-TB: All-oral regimen including Bedaquiline, Levofloxacin, and possibly Linezolid

Key Monitoring Points

  • Baseline liver function tests before starting INH, RIF, or PZA
  • Visual acuity and color vision testing when EMB is part of regimen
  • Serum uric acid levels if PZA is used for more than 6 weeks
  • Quarterly ECGs for patients on Bedaquiline or Levofloxacin
  • Peripheral neuropathy assessment in patients on INH; give pyridoxine 25 mg daily

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Skipping pyridoxine with INH → leads to numbness or tingling
  • Not checking drug interactions with RIF → affects contraceptives, antiretrovirals, anticoagulants
  • Using Streptomycin without auditory monitoring → early hearing loss can be irreversible
  • Stopping therapy early due to mild liver enzyme rise → small increases are common
  • Prescribing Bedaquiline without ECG baseline → missed QT prolongation can cause arrhythmia

When a doctor needs to treat tuberculosis, the first drug that often comes to mind is Isoniazid. But the landscape of TB therapy includes several other agents, each with its own strengths and drawbacks. This guide walks you through the most common alternatives, compares their key attributes, and helps you decide which one fits a particular case.

What is Isoniazid?

Isoniazid is a bactericidal antibiotic specifically active against Mycobacterium tuberculosis. It is classified as a first‑line anti‑TB drug and is often used in both active disease and latent infection.

  • Typical adult dose: 5mg/kg (max 300mg) daily.
  • Key side effects: hepatotoxicity, peripheral neuropathy (preventable with pyridoxine).
  • Mechanism: inhibits mycolic acid synthesis, compromising the bacterial cell wall.

How Rifampin

Rifampin is a broad‑spectrum antibiotic that also targets the bacterial RNA polymerase. It is a cornerstone of the standard four‑drug regimen for active TB.

  • Typical adult dose: 10mg/kg (max 600mg) daily.
  • Key side effects: orange‑red body fluids, liver enzyme elevation, drug‑drug interactions.
  • Use: active TB, also effective for latent infection when combined with Isoniazid.

Understanding Ethambutol

Ethambutol interferes with the bacterial cell wall by blocking arabinogalactan synthesis. It is added to prevent resistance when the patient’s bacterial load is high.

  • Typical adult dose: 15-25mg/kg daily.
  • Key side effects: optic neuritis (vision changes), which are reversible if detected early.
  • Role: part of the initial intensive phase in drug‑sensitive TB.

Pyrazinamide

Pyrazinamide works best in acidic environments, such as the intracellular compartments where TB bacteria hide. It shortens the overall treatment duration.

  • Typical adult dose: 20-25mg/kg daily for the first two months.
  • Key side effects: hyperuricemia, hepatotoxicity.
  • Use: intensive‑phase drug in the standard regimen.
Assorted colored TB pills and a vial with a stethoscope on a wooden tray.

When Streptomycin

Streptomycin is an injectable aminoglycoside that disrupts protein synthesis. It is now reserved for multidrug‑resistant (MDR) TB or when oral options are limited.

  • Typical adult dose: 15mg/kg intramuscularly daily.
  • Key side effects: ototoxicity, nephrotoxicity.
  • Current status: not part of first‑line therapy in most countries.

Exploring Levofloxacin

Levofloxacin is a fluoroquinolone with activity against TB strains resistant to first‑line drugs. It is taken orally and penetrates well into lung tissue.

  • Typical adult dose: 750mg daily.
  • Key side effects: tendon rupture, QT prolongation, gastrointestinal upset.
  • Indication: MDR‑TB regimens, alternative when rifampin cannot be used.

The newer Bedaquiline

Bedaquiline targets the ATP synthase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, a mechanism not shared by older drugs. It has become a vital component of the all‑oral MDR‑TB regimen.

  • Typical adult dose: 400mg daily for 2 weeks, then 200mg three times per week.
  • Key side effects: QT interval prolongation, hepatic enzyme elevation.
  • Regulatory status: approved by WHO for MDR‑TB under careful cardiac monitoring.

The disease context: Tuberculosis

Tuberculosis (TB) is an infectious disease caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis, affecting primarily the lungs but capable of spreading to any organ. Treatment success hinges on selecting the right drug combination for the right duration.

Doctor reviewing ECG and liver monitor while patient sits by an eye chart.

Side‑by‑side comparison of the main agents

Key attributes of Isoniazid and its common alternatives
Drug Class Typical Dose (Adult) Primary Use Major Side Effects Resistance Risk
Isoniazid First‑line bactericidal 5mg/kg daily (max 300mg) Latent TB, part of 4‑drug regimen Hepatotoxicity, peripheral neuropathy Low when used with other first‑line drugs
Rifampin First‑line bactericidal 10mg/kg daily (max 600mg) Active TB, part of 4‑drug regimen Hepatic enzyme rise, orange fluids, interactions Moderate; synergy reduces risk
Ethambutol First‑line bacteriostatic 15‑25mg/kg daily Active TB, especially high‑bacillary load Optic neuritis, color vision loss Low when combined
Pyrazinamide First‑line bactericidal (acidic pH) 20‑25mg/kg daily (2 months) Intensive phase of active TB Hepatotoxicity, hyperuricemia Low with proper combination
Streptomycin Second‑line injectable aminoglycoside 15mg/kg IM daily MDR‑TB, when oral options limited Ototoxicity, nephrotoxicity High if used alone
Levofloxacin Fluoroquinolone (second‑line) 750mg daily MDR‑TB, rifampin‑intolerant cases Tendon rupture, QT prolongation Moderate; resistance develops quickly
Bedaquiline Diarylquinoline (novel) 400mg daily 2wks, then 200mg TIW MDR‑TB, part of all‑oral regimens QT prolongation, hepatic effects Low when combined with other new drugs

Choosing the right drug: practical decision points

Here are some concrete scenarios and what they imply for drug selection:

  • Latent infection in a healthy adult: Isoniazid alone for 6‑9months (or a 3‑month weekly Isoniazid‑rifapentine combo). No need for the other agents.
  • Newly diagnosed drug‑sensitive pulmonary TB: The classic four‑drug regimen (Isoniazid, Rifampin, Ethambutol, Pyrazinamide) for two months, followed by Isoniazid‑Rifampin for four months.
  • Hepatic impairment: Reduce or omit Isoniazid and Pyrazinamide; consider a regimen based on Rifampin, Ethambutol, and a fluoroquinolone.
  • Pregnancy: Isoniazid and Rifampin are generally safe; avoid Streptomycin because of fetal ototoxicity.
  • MDR‑TB (resistance to Isoniazid and Rifampin): Build an all‑oral regimen including Bedaquiline, Levofloxacin, and possibly linezolid, guided by susceptibility testing.

Monitoring and managing side effects

Regardless of the chosen drug, regular follow‑up is essential.

  1. Baseline liver function tests (ALT/AST) before starting Isoniazid, Rifampin, or Pyrazinamide.
  2. Visual acuity and color vision testing at month 1 and month 2 when Ethambutol is part of the regimen.
  3. Serum uric acid levels if Pyrazinamide is used for more than six weeks.
  4. Quarterly ECGs for patients on Bedaquiline or Levofloxacin, especially if they have cardiac risk factors.
  5. Peripheral neuropathy assessment in patients on Isoniazid; give pyridoxine 25mg daily to prevent nerve damage.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

Even seasoned clinicians can trip up. Below are typical mistakes and quick fixes.

  • Skipping pyridoxine with Isoniazid: Leads to numbness or tingling. Always prescribe 25mg pyridoxine daily.
  • Not checking drug interactions with Rifampin: Rifampin induces many cytochromeP450 enzymes, lowering the levels of contraceptives, antiretrovirals, and some anticoagulants. Review the patient’s medication list thoroughly.
  • Using Streptomycin without auditory monitoring: Early hearing loss can be irreversible. Conduct baseline audiometry and repeat after two weeks.
  • Stopping therapy early because of mild liver enzyme rise: Small, transient increases are common; continue with close monitoring unless enzymes rise > three times the upper limit.
  • Prescribing Bedaquiline without ECG baseline: Missed QT prolongation can precipitate arrhythmia. Get a baseline ECG and repeat monthly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Isoniazid alone for active TB?

No. For active disease, Isoniazid must be combined with other drugs (Rifampin, Ethambutol, Pyrazinamide) to prevent resistance and ensure cure.

Is Rifampin safe during pregnancy?

Rifampin is generally considered safe in pregnancy and is included in WHO’s recommended regimen for pregnant women with TB.

What is the advantage of Bedaquiline over older drugs?

Bedaquiline targets a novel bacterial enzyme, making it effective against strains that resist Isoniazid and Rifampin. It also allows an all‑oral regimen, avoiding painful injections.

How long should I take Isoniazid for latent TB?

The standard course is 6months, though a 9‑month regimen is used when adherence is a concern. A 3‑month weekly Isoniazid‑rifapentine combo is another evidence‑based option.

Do I need to monitor blood sugar while on Pyrazinamide?

Pyrazinamide can raise uric acid, not blood sugar. Routine glucose checks aren’t required unless the patient has diabetes.

About Author

Elara Nightingale

Elara Nightingale

I am a pharmaceutical expert and often delve into the intricate details of medication and supplements. Through my writing, I aim to provide clear and factual information about diseases and their treatments. Living in a world where health is paramount, I feel a profound responsibility for ensuring that the knowledge I share is both accurate and useful. My work involves continuous research and staying up-to-date with the latest pharmaceutical advancements. I believe that informed decisions lead to healthier lives.

Comments (1)

  1. Angela Allen Angela Allen

    Hey folks, great rundown! I especially love how you highlighted the need for pyridoxine with INH – it saves a lot of nerve pain. Keep it up!

Write a comment